Image of Little Gryphon

 

Ink and Bone

The Great Library series, Book 1

New American Library
Fiction, YA Fantasy
Themes: Alchemy, Alternate Earths, Books and Libraries, Dystopias, Schools, Thieves, Magic Workers
****

Description

From birth, Jess Brightwell's life has been defined by books - contraband items outside the all-powerful Great Library, which has controlled the flow of information worldwide for centuries. His father's trade in illegal original tomes puts Jess and his family in constant danger, with the Library's well-armed High Garda and cruel, alchemy-powered automata mercilessly hunting down traders. While Jess loves books, he cannot reconcile himself to dealing with the often unsavory clients of the family business... which is why Jess's father has decided that he'd better serve the Brightwells as an insider, joining the ranks of the Library to learn of new treasures and impending threats. Much as Jess has learned to fear the Library, he can't help but be excited: after all, to the average citizen, the Library represents the knowledge and wisdom of the ages, the bright light that guides all of humanity toward a better tomorrow, and just think of the countless books hidden away in the archives! But Jess soon learns that the gilded cover hides a rotten heart, as he's plunged into a world where nobody can be trusted and no secret is safe.

Review

If knowledge is power and power corrupts, does absolute control of knowledge corrupt absolutely? Rachel Caine posits a near-future world where alchemy is real, exploited by master librarians to limit the vital resource of information. Several familiar assumptions (particularly for "Western" readers used to English- or American-centered stories) get tweaked, here; English-born Jess was proud of how intelligent his childhood spent around illegal books has made him, only to realize he's barely average compared to the rest of Europe, who themselves pale in comparison to Middle Eastern nations who have had centuries longer to enjoy access to the Great Library's fruits (it having been founded in Ancient Egypt.) As for America, it's essentially a police state, considered a lowlife hotbed for rebels and Burners, a violent faction espousing the dangerous view that human lives should matter more than books. No institution has clean hands in this world, and no characters here are free from faults or sins. Jess must navigate a maze of traps, not just those set by his stern, borderline-cruel teacher Wolfe - a man who also has a hidden past and his own agenda and who isn't above endangering lives to pursue it. Jess's upbringing among criminals serves him in surprisingly good stead as he finds himself surrounded by untrustworthy peers and questionable superiors, not to mention his own family and their contacts who make periodic demands of him; Jess's twin brother Brendan, who aims to follow in their father's illegal footsteps, proves a strange mix of ally and rival. It's a trial by fire for Jess and the rest of the students he's training with as they compete for a limited number of openings within the Great Library, all for their own reasons. The tale moves at a good clip, with several turns (many of them dark), setting up what looks to be an intense series. Once in a while, Jess seemed a little naive given his background and what he should've already known, but on the whole he made a believable, if flawed, character, as did the rest of the cast. I expect I'll pursue the next volume in the series, at least.

 

Return to Top of Page

 

Ill Wind

The Weather Warden series, Book 1

Roc
Fiction, Fantasy
Themes: Bonded Familiars, Country Stories, Curses, Demons, Girl Power, Hidden Wonders, Magic Workers
***+

Description

Storms, fires, earthquakes... Mother Nature wants us dead, and but for the Wardens she might have succeeded ages ago. A secret global association does its best to defuse and mitigate the worst disasters, recruiting rare people gifted with power over the elements and employing captive Djinn. But gifts don't come without risks or costs, and the dangers of a rogue Warden - or, worse, one infested with a demon - are worse than anything Nature can concoct.
Joanne Baldwin has always had a strange connection to the weather, and was recruited as a teenager into the Warden Association. She was a bright rising star in the organization. Now she's on the run, accused of murder and bearing a Demon Mark. Her only hope lies in reaching Lewis, a former friend and fellow outcast from the Association, before the Mark devours her powers and her very soul. But first she has to outrun the Association's trackers, assorted Djinn, and a sentient, predatory storm - not to mention someone who is trying very, very hard to kill her.

Review

This modern fantasy establishes a hidden network of mages and Djinn and malevolent natural phenomena... all bound to the viewpoint of a character I wanted to smack across the face more than once. Joanna is one of those protagonists who can be mind-numbingly oblivious about obvious things and behaves in such obnoxious ways that she didn't even pause at "endearingly quirky" before she hit "outright aggravating." She deliberately refuses to seek or accept help, actively ignoring advice and obvious clues, even as she flirts with anything remotely masculine out of sheer reflex. (And, of course, every male wants to sleep with her, because she's just that hot.) At one point, while she's on the run from various people trying to kill her, she stops at a mall for fresh clothes and deliberately picks out a lacy tight top (with no bra) to tease a hitchhiker she picks up... then pouts that he doesn't notice, even though she actively and aggressively told him to get lost shortly before the pouting fit. Other things, she's simply far too slow on the uptake about, to the point I was (figuratively) shouting at her for a good third of the tale. This is who I had to follow through the book. Add to that how Caine dances around what actually happened to Joanne for a good portion of the book, indulging in prolonged flashbacks that deliberately avoid the matter... I won't lie: teeth were ground more than once. The story itself, when it isn't flashing back and once it finally lets me in on enough of the world's rules and Joanne's story for me to engage with it, moves fairly well, building to a climax and a surprisingly solid ending, one that might tempt me to the next book in the series. My overall annoyance with Joanne, though, costs the book a half-star in the ratings.

 

Return to Top of Page