Barker - Book Reviews

***** - Excellent
**** - Good
*** - Okay
** - Bad
* - Terrible
+ - Half-star

Abarat
(The Abarat series, Book 1)
Clive Barker
HarperCollins
Fiction, YA Fantasy
**

DESCRIPTION: Candy Quackenbush lives in the most boring town in Minnesota - the encyclopedias in the library even confirm it. Aside from being the top producer of chicken meat, Chickentown holds no other points of interest... and Candy has one more day to finish her class assignment of finding ten "interesting" things about the place. She hates this place, just as she hates her life, living always in fear of her alcoholic father and with a mother too cowed to stand up for her children. There has to be more to look forward to than an eternity in this nowhere town!
After failing her school project, Candy finally snaps. She runs out on school, on home, on the town itself, heading into the trackless prairie grasses - and straight into the path of a very peculiar fellow. John Mischief is eight brothers in one, with seven little heads atop antlers sprouting from his skull. Through him, Candy finds herself pulled into a strange and magical world, the archipelago of Abarat. She always wanted to leave dreary old Chickentown behind her, but Abarat is no Wonderland. Danger lurks behind every wonder, and some of the attention she attracts could well be the death of her.

REVIEW: When modern galleries feature bizarre items in their displays, such as urinals or trash cans, people often ask: is it really art? Its presence in an art gallery would seem to qualify it as art, even if it seems unrecognizable as such. Likewise, as I read Abarat, I found myself constantly wondering if it was really a story; the fact that it appears to be printed on paper and bound inside a cover would seem to qualify it as one, though at several points it seemed unrecognizable as such.
With more surreality than Alice in Wonderland but none of the whimsical turns of phrase, Abarat presents a bland heroine who wanders from one bizarre situation to the next, meeting all manner of improbable beings with little more than an occassional hint of wonder. Unlike Alice, she doesn't even have the excuse of being in a dream; she's wide awake the whole time, yet seems largely unphased by a man with little heads living on his antlers or fishlike creatures playing cards on a rolling ocean. (There is an explanation for some of her accepting behavior, but it felt entirely unsatisfactory and, frankly, like a cop-out.) You would think that a modern kid would be a little more incredulous, or a little more cynical, pointing out the ridiculous impracticalities she witnesses in her journeys, but Candy just drifts through it all, so happy to be out of Chickentown that she hardly gives any of it a second thought. The plot drifts with her, only barely establishing a greater mytharc about impending threats to the islands of the Arabat... a mytharc that's left entirely unresolved by the end. Since I never cared for the heroine, and could work up no interest in the fates of any of the other characters, I won't be following Abarat into the next book. Apparently, that revelation was supposed to excuse the wandering nature of the story: I wasn't reading a whole book, but merely an introduction. If I'd known that I wouldn't even be rewarded with a conclusion, I wouldn't have bothered slogging through to the bitter end.
Much like that peculiar modern art that leaves me scratching my head more often than not, I can only say about Abarat that I may not know art, but I know what I like... and what I don't like.

You might also enjoy:
Demons Don't Dream (Piers Anthony, Fiction - A computer game leads two kids into the magical world of Xanth, where magic and puns abound)
Dream a Little Dream (Piers Anthony and Julie Brady, Fiction - A dark force threatens Kafka, the world created by human dreams)
The Everworld series (K. A. Applegate, YA Fiction - Four Chicago teens are pulled into a world where magic and elder gods reign)
Peter Pan (James M. Barrie, YA Fiction - The boy who refuses to grow up leads three English children to the magical island of Neverland)
The Wizard of Oz (L. Frank Baum, YA Fiction - The classic American fairy tale of young Dorothy, swept from Kansas into a magical world)
A Hollow World: Down the Rabbit Hole (R. G. Beckwith, Fiction - A young scientist, fresh out of college, joins a government team investigating a mysterious hole in Greenland)
Magic Kingdom For Sale - Sold! (Terry Brooks, Fiction - A laywer buys a magic kingdom in a catalog)
A Princess of Mars (Edgar Rice Burroughs, Fiction - A Civil War veteran finds himself transported to the dying, hostile planet Mars)
Storybound (Marissa Burt, YA Fiction - A girl falls into the world of Story)
The Best of Lewis Carroll (Lewis Carrol, YA Fiction - Classic tales by Lewis Carroll, including Alice in Wonderland, Through the Looking Glass, and more)
Gregor the Overlander (Suzanne Collins, YA Fiction - A modern boy and his toddler sister fall into a dark, strange world beneath New York City)
The Wiz Biz books (Rich Cook, Fiction - A Silicon Valley programmer is pulled into a magical world)
The Last of the Really Great Whangdoodles (Julie Andrews Edwards, YA Fiction - A professor and three children seek the world of the fanciful Whangdoodle, which can only be found through the power of imagination)
Coraline (Neil Gaiman, YA Fiction - A girl finds a surreal mirror version of her flat)
Librarian: Little Boy Lost (Eric Hobbs, YA Fiction - A bookish boy discovers secrets and dangers in a mysterious library)
The Dark World (Henry Kuttner, Fiction - A World War II vet finds himself in a parallel world of magic, fighting memories of an alternate, evil self)
Every Heart a Doorway (Seanan McGuire, YA? Fiction - A teen girl attends a boarding school for children traumatized by adventures in magical worlds... where students start turning up dead)
Un Lun Dun (China Miéville, YA Fiction - Two English schoolgirls find their way to the bizarre "abcity" mirror of London)
The Chronicles of the Imaginarium Geographica (James A. Owen, YA Fiction - Three Englishmen travel to the Archipelago of Dreams, inspiration for story and myth since the world began)
The Curious World of Shelley Vendor (Colin R. Parsons, YA Fiction - A clumsy girl follows alien book-thieves into a dangerous world)
The Diadem series (John Peel, YA Fiction - A strange messenger plucks three children from three worlds for a special quest)
The Takers (R. W. Ridley, YA Fiction - 13-year-old Oz Griffin wakes from a fever to find that invisible monsters, escaped from a dead boy's comic book, have devastated the world)
Jake Ransom and the Skull King's Shadow (James Rollins, YA Fiction - An ancient artifact pulls two teens into a lost world)
The Imaginality of Somewhere (Someone, YA Fiction - Twins discover a portal to a magical world)
The High House (James Stoddard, Fiction - A vast, surreal house encompasses whole worlds and touches on others)
The Rhyme of the Willow series (Justin Sullivan and Samuel Sullivan, YA Fiction - Following a vivid dream, twins find themselves pulled into a dark world where plants run amok)
The Girl Who Circumnavigated Fairyland in a Ship of Her Own Making (Catherynne M. Valente, YA Fiction - An Omaha girl travels to Fairyland for an Adventure, and finds herself fighting an evil Marquess)
The War of the Flowers (Tad Williams, Fiction - A man finds himself in the world of Faerie, where magic has grown in a twisted mockery of technology)
The 100 Cupboards trilogy (N. D. Wilson, YA Fiction - A boy on a Kansas farm finds mysterious cupboard doors leading to other worlds)

Return to Top of Page - Return to Book Review List

Return to Brightdreamer Books Home

Brightdreamer Books is created and maintained by TBW, a.k.a. "Brightdreamer."
E-mail: tbweber AT comcast DOT net. Remove spaces, replace AT with "@" and DOT with "." - please put "Brightdreamer Books" in the subject line, or your e-mail may be deleted as spam! Thank you!